Highest Paying Casinos in NJ 2024

Not everybody plays online casino games for fun, some of us play strictly to win. If so, have you ever considered the fact that different games may lead to different turnouts? That’s right, while the large variety of games can be quite overwhelming, in this guide we will help you identify the games that give you the best odds to increase your chances of winning big. So if you want to find out more about the highest paying casinos then keep on reading because we’re just getting started.

Highest Paying Casinos Table of Contents

Introduction to the Highest Paying Casinos – House Edge and RTP

Before we can tell you about the best paying casinos and the best paying casino games, we first need to make sure you understand the basics of online gambling. To do that, we need to teach you about the pillars that keep this industry alive today, and they are as follows:

House Edge – How It Affects the Best Paying Online Casinos

Whether you are playing an online or an offline casino game, they both have a built-in house edge. Without this house edge, the casinos would not be able to exist today. This is because the house edge is the reason why they can even make a profit in the first place. However, just because it helps the casinos does not mean it also makes it impossible for you to win. If the players never won anything then they would stop playing, which would hurt the casinos a lot more in the long run.

With that said, if you plan on playing at any NJ online casinos, you should know that the house edge depends on the game that you’re playing.


For the most part, slot games have a higher house edge than table games. Despite that, keep in mind that this may vary depending on the game that you play. If you takeonline sots for example, there are some titles that offer you a house edge of 8% or higher, while others will limit you to 4% or less.

Table Games

Some of the best paying casino games are table games, but then again those are the exceptions to the rule. As a general rule, online blackjack and online video poker usually have a lower house edge than online slots.

The main reason why so many players lose money on those games is because they do not know how to play them correctly. Casinos tend to take advantage of those people. A lot of them mistakenly believe that games like online baccarat for example are all about luck. The truth is that luck can only get you so far. Choose the games with a lower house edge so that you can win more and lose less money.

Return to Player – Why it’s Important for the Best Paying Casinos

The Return to Player, or RTP for short, is the opposite of what the house edge represents. For instance, if the game that you’re playing has a house edge of 5.26% you will have an RTP of 94.76%. Those numbers may sound good to you, but remember that that’s just the standard for online casinos. A game that almost always has that house edge and RTP is American Roulette for example.

However, try to remember that the RTP is not a reliable indicator of how high your chances of winning are. Instead, the final results of the game are a lot more dependent on RNG and your own personal skill. At the same time, knowing the RTP of the game that you’re playing can help you make better choices in the game.

The RTP at its base level is just a mathematical equation that is based on thousands of outcomes at the same time. This is an attempt to predict the likely percentage of the total amount wagered on that game the casino will return to the players. If you play a thousand matches of the same game, your results are likely to look similar to those predicted by the RTP. Use this for your own good to determine what the best paying online casino is for you.

Top 10 Highest Paying Casinos in New Jersey 2024

The New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement (NJDGE) always makes sure that no matter what, every licensed operator pays its players when they win. So, as long as your casino is licensed, you will get your money a hundred percent of the time.

Alternatively, if you want to make sure that you get a good deal, you should always aim for the highest paying casinos around. Here are the top 10 best paying casinos as of 2024:

RankCasino NameRatingPayoutSpecial Bonus
 1888 Casino9298.1%120% Deposit Bonus up to $500
 2Golden Nugget9597.86%100% up to $1000 Deposit Match
 3BetMGM9596.16%100% Deposit Match up to $1000
 5SugarHouse/BetRivers9397.87%100% Deposit Match up to $250
 6DraftKings9596.20%$2000 Deposit Match
 7Borgata Online9496.06%100% Deposit Match up to $1000
 8Hard Rock Bet8995.5%
 9PartyCasino9296%$1000 Deposit Match Bonus
 10Virgin Casino9197.21%Up to $100 Real Cash Back

Casinos Overviews

Now that we’ve set the stage with our list of the Top 10 Highest Paying Casinos in New Jersey for 2024, it’s time to dig a little deeper. In the following section, we’ll provide individual overviews of these standout casinos.

888 Casino

This online casino features well over 1,000 games for you to play whenever you feel lucky. Not only that but 888 Casino also offers plenty of free spins along the way on top of the incredible 120% Deposit Bonus of up to $500 offer.

Golden Nugget

When you play at Golden Nugget Online Casino NJ you already know that you’re playing at one of the best locations in all of Atlantic City. Their game library extends to a lot of top-rated games, and not only that but its 100% up to $1000 deposit match bonus dwarves most other casinos.


Known for its cutting-edge technology, BetMGM Online Casino NJ also has a large range of games from slots to live dealer games. On top of that, BetMGM also features a 100% Deposit Match up to $1000, which makes playing and coming out on top a breeze.


BetRivers, the former Sugarhouse brand, is a bit of a tough recommendation to make. This is because even though their game selection is not as large as some of the other titles on this list, they more than make up for that through their quality.

You will only find around 400 games, with around 300 slots available to you.  But, the former SugarHouse Online Casino is known for the incredible 100% Deposit Match of up to $500 and an equal value Risk Free Bet.


DraftKings Casino NJ has been around for a very long time now, and it’s only gotten more popular in recent years. Even though it has switched its focus to sports betting, it still has a large game selection, and on top of that it is known as one of the highest paying casinos in the US today.

Borgata Online

Borgata is one of those online casinos that knows how to get your attention and keep it for a very long time. Most other casinos pale in comparison to Borgata Online Casino and its 100% Deposit Match up to $1,000 Bonus. On top of that, they also have one of the largest game libraries in the world, and the quality of said games is through the roof.

Hard Rock Bet

Hard Rock Online Casino has made great strides toward becoming one of the highest-paying casinos, particularly through its recent rebranding efforts. The Hard Rock Bet rebrand had a dramatic effect on increasing payout rates across both sports betting and online casino games. The newly upgraded portfolio now offers games with high Return to Player (RTP) percentages, making them increasingly profitable options for players.

Party Casino

The same can be said about PartyCasino Online, where you can also partake in a $500 Deposit Match Bonus. On top of that the PartyCasino App NJ is one of the fastest and easiest to browse platforms we’ve ever come across.

Virgin Casino

Last but not least on our list we have Virgin Casino Online. By simply using their platform you will get access to a special bonus of Up to $100 Real Cash Back. Additionally, they feature a really good payout of 97.21% which is well worth the investment.


While it is one of the newest online casinos in NJ, it is still worth looking into if you want to have a good time. One of the main benefits of investing in such a new property is the fact that there will be a lot of good deals coming out soon that will reward you for your time.

Fastest Paying Online Casinos in NJ

RankOnline CasinoRecommended Payout OptionPayout Speed
 1BetRivers Casino NJPayPal, Play+Instant
2PokerStars Casino NJCredit/debit cards, Echecks1 Hour
3Caesars Palace Casino8-24 hours8-24 Hours
 4Bally Casino NJPayPal1 Day
 5Virgin Casino NJPayPal1 Day
 6DraftKings Casino NJPayPal, Play+1 Day
 7BetMGM Casino NJPayPal1 Day
BetWay Casino NJPayPal1-3 Days
 10PlayStar Casino NJPlay+3-5 Days

Keep in mind however that even the fastest paying online casinos still have an internal review period between 24 hours and five days in the worst-case scenario. With that said, as soon as the internal review is over and your withdrawal is approved, your payment will be sent through in a matter of minutes.

Caesars Palace Casino

Caesars Palace Casino NJ sets the bar when it comes to luxurious gaming experiences when it comes to quick payouts. Recently, they’ve upped the ante with the Caesars Palace Casino app launch, which was a pivotal move in the Caesars Online Casino rebrand process. This redesign goes far beyond aesthetics. It has also greatly expanded the Caesars promotions offerings. Therefore, both the casino Caesars Bonus and the Caesars Risk Free Bet make it simpler for players to engage in gaming activities and manage their finances.

  • Caesars Bonus: $10 + $1000 deposit match + 2,500 rewards points
  • Playthrough: $10 Free Play: 1x slots, 2x video poker, 5x other games; Deposit Match: 15x slots, 30x video poker games, and 75x on other games.
  • Caesars Risk Free Bet: $1000 Second Chance Bet
  • Fastest Withdrawal: PayPal
  • Other Withdrawal Options: Play+ Card, Caesars Casino Atlantic City
white caesars palace casino logo featuring the roman figure

BetRivers Casino NJ

This is one of the fastest paying online casinos in New Jersey. Additionally, BetRivers Online Casino NJ is considered to be one of the most trustworthy online casinos in Atlantic City, and for good reason too.
Their services are unmatched, and on top of that, making a BetRivers withdrawal couldn’t be any easier. Here is what you need to know about this online casino, and most importantly, the BetRivers casino bonus offering:

  • Deposit Match Bonus – Up To $500
  • Playthrough requirement – 1x
  • Fastest withdrawal methods – Play+, PayPal
  • Other withdrawal methods – Cash at the Golden Nugget cage, ACH eCheck
BetRivers NJ casino logo

PokerStars Casino NJ

PokerStars Casino NJ has carved out a reputation for offering a diverse range of casino games alongside its famed poker rooms. In keeping with the times, the casino has optimized its financial operations to make them as fast as the gameplay, allowing players to get their winnings with ease. But winning will become even more motivating with the Pokerstars Casino promotions. You can claim a PokerStars Casino bonus if you value online casino games. Moreover, there is also a very tempting PokerStars no deposit bonus on the line.

  • Deposit Bonus: $600 Deposit Match
  • Playthrough: Bet $1 on casino gaming or participate in one Cash Game hand
  • Fastest Withdrawal: PayPal
  • Other Withdrawal Options: Credit/Debit card, PayNearMe, Online Banking
PokerStars casino NJ white logo

BetMGM Casino NJ

When it comes to withdrawing methods, very few online casinos can match what BetMGM Online Casino NJ has to offer. This is among the oldest online casinos in NJ, and not only that but it also features one of the best MGM Rewards programs in the world. Here is everything else you need to know about BetMGM:

  • 100% Deposit Match up to $1000
  • Playthrough requirement – 15x
  • Fastest withdrawal methods – PayPal
  • Other withdrawal methods – Play+, Skrill, check by mail, Cash at Borgata AC cage, online banking
BetMGM online casino NJ logo

Bally Casino NJ

Next up we have Bally Online Casino NJ, yet another amazing casino that brings to the table plenty of withdrawal options as well as some of the fastest paying times around. Usually, it only takes a few hours for your withdrawal to be processed, but in some cases, it can also take over a day. Here is everything else you need to know about Bally’s:

  • Deposit Bonus – $100 Risk-Free Play
  • Playthrough requirement – 100% refunded in case you lose all of your matches within the first 7 days
  • Fastest withdrawal method – PayPal
  • Other withdrawal methods – ACH, Visa/Mastercard, Cash at Bally’s Atlantic City cage
Bally online casino NJ

Virgin Casino NJ

Most withdrawals on Virgin Casino NJ are processed within 24 hours or less. As such, it is considered to be one of the fastest paying casinos in New Jersey. With that said, here is everything you need to know about it:

  • Deposit Bonus – Up To $100 Real Cash Back
  • Playthrough requirement – none
  • Fastest withdrawal methods – PayPal
  • Other withdrawal methods – ACH, cash at Tropicana Atlantic City, check by mail
Virgin casino online logo

DraftKings Casino NJ

DraftKings is the type of casino that fully invests in its security to make sure that the players are always safe while gaming on their platform. As such, both the withdrawals and the deposits at DraftKings take a bit longer to process. At the same time, it is considered to be one of the highest paying casinos in New Jersey. Here is what you need to know about it:

  • Deposit Bonus – $2000 Deposit Match
  • Playthrough requirement – 1x to 15x
  • Fastest withdrawal methods – PayPal, Play+
  • Other withdrawal methods – Check by mail, VISA/MasterCard, and online banking
DraftKings Casino Logo

Betway Casino NJ

While it may be one of the newer NJ online casinos, Betway Online Casino NJ is still a great option you should not miss out on. It is trustworthy and very lucrative and it has already been referred to by many as being one of the highest paying casinos in NJ. On top of that, you have the following:

  • Deposit Bonus – 100% Match Bonus Up To $1000
  • Playthrough requirement – 30x
  • Fastest withdrawal methods – PayPal
  • Other withdrawal methods – ACH, Cash at Golden Nugget AC cage, Play+
Betway NJ casino logo

PlayStar Casino NJ

Last but not least on our list we have PlayStar Online Casino NJ. While it may also lack in the withdrawal options department, it more than makes up for that with its speed and first deposit bonus:

  • Deposit Bonus – Up to $500
  • Playthrough requirement – 30x
  • Fastest withdrawal methods – Play+
  • Other withdrawal methods – cash at Ocean Casino Resort Cage
PlayStar Casino NJ sliver logo

What Separates Slots from Other Casino Games

Slots are unique compared to other casino games. This is because they are based on luck, as opposed to other table games such as Online Craps where luck is also a major factor that you need to take into consideration. Therefore, slots will also usually have lower wagering requirements for clearing bonuses.

Top 5 Highest Paying Online Slots in NJ Casinos

There are a lot of Online Slots that you can play. If you are only playing for fun, then you can play whatever game is to your liking. There are a lot of different themed slots out there that specifically cater to your hobbies or preferred franchises. However, if you want to win big, then you need to find the games that have the highest RTP ratio around. Here is a list of the most prominent AC slots for instance:

All of these games have an average RTP of around 94.94%. But again, if you do not like playing these games then you don’t need to. The beauty of NJ online casinos is that they have thousands upon thousands of games for you to choose from.

CasinoGame #1Game #2Game #3Game #4Game #5
Caesars Online CasinoRise of the Mountain King Secret of the Stones MAXRaging Rhino Megaways300 Shields ExtremeBlack Knight
Borgata Online CasinoThunderstruck IIWish MasterExtra ChiliMontezumaDivine Fortune
BetMGM Online CasinoBook of Dead300 Shields ExtremeVikings Go WildGooniesReactoonz
FanDuel Online Casino88 FortunesCleopatraDead or Alive IIUltimate Fire LinkJungle Spirit Call of the Wild
DraftKings Online CasinoGonzo’s QuestCleopatraWheel of Fortune Megaways88 FortunesBonanza

What Qualifies as the Highest Paying Casino Game?

Regardless of which casino game you’re playing, luck will always be a major factor you must consider. However, why is it that Blackjack and Video Poker always have the highest RTP percentage? The answer is simple, these games require a certain degree of skill to win, which is why they have a much higher RTP.

At the same time though, keep in mind that progressive jackpot games tend to have a much lower RTP. This is because playing these games is generally much more cost-effective, and at the same time you have the chance to win a huge jackpot while playing.

Is Blackjack the Highest Paying Casino Game?

As mentioned, the house edge is the part of the equation that results in how much profit a casino expects to make on the game in the long run. The higher the house edge, the lower the RTP will be, so generally you should stay away from games that have a high house edge.

Now that we have that out of the way, how can we quantify blackjack in terms of profitability for the player? Well, we just need to look at the house edge and the RTP that the casino offers for blackjack matches. Luckily, no matter what online casino you’re playing at, you’ll find that most of them have a house edge of less than 1% on blackjack games. This means that the casinos expect to make around $1 or less for every $100 bet on the game. With those odds, you may feel inclined to spend all your time playing blackjack, right? Keep in mind however that the exact percentage of the house edge is also based on the following house rules:

House Rules

How the Rules Affect the House Edge in Blackjack

For each particular deck that is being used, the house edge goes up exponentially. At the same time, if you get paid 6:5 instead of 3:2 on blackjack then that will also make it go up. Additionally, the house edge will increase by up to 0.2% if the dealer hits on soft 17. If you can double down, the house edge will increase from 0.09 to 0.15% on 9 or 11, and from 0.17 to 0.26% when you can double down on 10 or 11. At the same time, if you can double down after splitting a pair, the house edge will be reduced by up to 0.12%. But if you are restricted to only splitting one time then that percentage goes back up.

If you are allowed to surrender then the game will also have a lower house edge. So, keep this in mind while playing, and always ask questions to make sure that the house edge and RTP are good enough to play the game.

The Highest Paying Casino Blackjack Games in New Jersey

In this section, we will go over some of the most popular online blackjack games available in New Jersey. We will also bring up each game’s rules and how they influence the game’s house edge.

Single-Deck Blackjack

This should be the go-to option for any gambler who wants to play with the best odds at any online casino game. The house edge here stands at a minuscule 0.13%, and the house edge is brought even lower by the fact that the dealer stands on soft 17.

Atlantic City Blackjack

Next up we have AC Blackjack, a title that has quite a few player-friendly rules that keep the house edge at 0.36%. Here are the rules:

High Stakes Blackjack

High stakes blackjack is unique in that it has a minimum bet of $50, but also a very low house edge of 0.36%. Here are the player-friendly rules that help keep that house edge at a minimum:

Vegas Strip Blackjack

With a very low house edge of only 0.36%, Vegas Strip Blackjack is a very fun and rewarding game that you can enjoy at most NJ online casinos. Here are some of the player-friendly rules that keep that house edge low:

Games with the Highest House Edge

While there are plenty of blackjack games that feature an incredibly low house edge, the opposite can also apply to others. You should avoid games that have these rules if you want to increase your chances of winning big:

Blackjack pays 6:5

Always opt for a blackjack payout of 3:2 because the 6:5 rule adds a whopping 1.4% to the house edge.

Dealer hits on soft 17

If the dealer gets to hit on soft 17 then the house edge will be up by 0.22%. Instead, always go for a blackjack table that forces the dealer to stand on soft 17.

No double after split

If the casino does not allow you to double after the split, then the house edge goes up by 0.14%.

Double on certain hands only

If you are not allowed to double down on any two cards, then the house edge will go up between 0.09% and 0.18%.

No surrender

If you are not allowed to surrender and give up half your bet then the house edge will go up by 0.08%.

No re-splitting aces

If you are not allowed to re-split your aces then the house edge will go up by 0.08% again.


The fewer decks are used, the lower the house edge. Therefore, if the blackjack games use two decks you will get a house edge of 0.19% while six decks will result in a house edge of 0.46%.

Responsible Gambling

Regardless of which games you choose to play or what odds you prefer to stick to, you should always remember to practice responsible gambling. This is because addiction can creep up on you before you know it, and when it does it’s incredibly difficult to keep it at bay. Luckily, there are more than a few methods that you can employ to make sure that you do not feed into your addiction.

For starters, you can limit your gaming time. Most online casinos offer you this option to make sure that you do not play more than you can or want to. Second of all, you can always limit the amount of money you can spend online. This is a very important limitation for those who have a history of betting too much money and leaving with less than they had initially. You will find both of these limitations in the Responsible Gambling section of the online casino you’re playing at.
Last but not least, if the problem persists you should contact the following institutions for help:

If you or anyone you know suffers from a gambling addiction, you need to check up on them and make sure that they’re okay. Also, do not hesitate to contact DGE at 608-984-9898 or email info@njdge.org directly if needed.

Invest in the Best Paying Casinos for a Better Outcome

If you want to maximize your chances of winning big, then you need to make sure that you opt for the best payout online casinos available. This means that you need to look into the following:

With that being said if you are only playing for fun, then you can discard all of this knowledge altogether. But if you want to win huge jackpots and lose as little money as possible, definitely keep in mind what we discussed so far in this guide.


Which casino has the best payout?

BetMGM is the highest-paying online casino.

What is the fastest paying casino?

BetRivers Casino NJ is the fastest paying casino available. It stands out for its high return-to-player (RTP) rates across a wide range of games. The platform is also transparent about its payout percentages and undergoes regular audits for fairness.

What casinos pay out immediately?

The online casinos with the fastest payouts are BetRivers, Bally Casino, and Virgin Casino. Not only do these casinos provide numerous fast and safe withdrawal methods, but they are renowned for their efficiency as well. Their commitment to immediate payouts sets them apart, making them highly sought after among players who want swift access to their winnings.

What day do casinos payout the most?

Casinos tend to offer their highest returns over weekends, particularly Friday through Sunday.
This period typically sees higher traffic and larger bets, leading to greater payout rates and faster payback rates. Many players consider the weekend the ideal opportunity for maximizing their winning potential in casinos.

What wins most at a casino?

Blackjack is the best game to play at a casino if you want to win. It has the best odds compared to other games, which means you’re more likely to make money. Many people prefer Blackjack because it’s also easy to learn. So, if you’re looking for a game where you can win more often, Blackjack is a good choice.